Directed by: David Fincher
Starring: Daniel Craig, Rooney Mara, Christopher Plummer, Stellan Skarsgard
First I need to give you my apologies, it’s been far too long since my last review, so you now may get quite a few in short succession!!
Secondly before reviewing this film, I feel the need to share my story, as it was very amusing…
So I was sat in the cinema with my friends, all prepared to watch The girl with the dragon tattoo, and the adverts start. I ask my one friend ‘so, have you read the book of this?’ she replies, ‘no’. I ask ‘Have you seen the foreign version?’ she replies ‘no, they did a foreign version of this?’ At this point, I’m getting a little nervous so feel the need to ask ‘You do know what this film is about don’t you?’ ……… ‘Yeah, isn’t it that cartoon film about dragons’.
oh dear.
Anyway, back to the review… I’m going to avoid making comparisons between this film and the original, for two reasons. 1) my memory of the original is a little hazy. 2) I feel that this film should be reviewed as a film in it’s own right.
There are a few negatives which I will discuss first. The opening titles were strange- I get they were meant to be symbolic but they were just strange, unnecessary and quite frankly alienating. I simply did not understand why they were there, and I feel the film could have been a lot more effective without them. I also feel that Daniel Craig was possibly not the most effective Michael Blomkvist. Don’t get me wrong, he did a good job, but to me, he just isn’t the character. Michael Blomkvist is not meant to be anyone special, he’s slightly above average but really that’s it, and they cast the current James Bond. I just don’t see it. I understand he shouldn’t be type-cast and I could see that there were changes made physically and within the character (such as his clumsiness) to make it better, but it was something that didn’t sit right with me.
I also didn’t like how every character spoke English but with a Swedish accent except Michael and his sister. To me that concept is pointless. Again, I can see why it was done so that everyone spoke English but with a Swedish accent, but if you’re going to do that make it so that EVERYONE does it, not just leave out two people. The lack of accent for Blomkvist and his sister lead me to question his character, is there some sort of history that I don’t know about? It just aggravated me. As you can see they are all fairly small points, and the overall film definitely won me over, these were just a few points I didn’t like!
Now on the plus side…..
It was gripping, brutal, funny, entertaining, tense, exciting… everything a film should be.
The acting was super. Rooney Mara did a brilliant job and really stood out in my mind. In fact I’ll be honest and every one acted brilliantly. Each scene captured the tension I felt when reading the book. The tension was slightly spoiled for me by the hilarious guy sat next to me with his running commentary of ‘that is disgusting’ and ‘he should be ashamed of himself’ but nonetheless, it was very tense!
Overall excellent cinema experience, excellently well done film. I just hope they do the next two, and that they are just as good!
8/10
